← Back to blog

Will vs shall: formal choices that sound natural

Por ProseBoost

Understanding the use of "will" and "shall" is crucial for expressing future intentions, predictions, and decisions in English. While both words are used to indicate future actions, their usage can vary based on context, formality, and regional preferences. This article explores the distinctions and applications of "will" and "shall" to help you communicate more effectively.

Future Intentions and Decisions

When discussing future plans or decisions, "will" is commonly used. It signifies what someone intends to do or what has already been decided. For instance, if Diane has a work schedule for next week, you would say, "Diane is working next week," rather than "Diane will work." This is because the schedule is already set, and "is working" reflects that arrangement.

Similarly, when asking about someone's plans, "are you going to" is often preferred over "will you," as it implies a more definite arrangement. For example, "Are you going to watch television this evening?" suggests a premeditated plan, whereas "Will you watch television this evening?" could imply a spontaneous decision.

Making Predictions

"Will" is frequently used to predict future events or situations. When you express what you think will happen, you're making a prediction. For example, if you believe Kate will succeed in her exam, you might say, "Do you think Kate will pass the exam?" Here, "will pass" reflects your prediction based on available information.

Consider these examples:

  • "Jill has been away a long time. When she returns, she’ll find a lot of changes here."
  • "Where will you be this time next year?" "I’ll be in Japan."
  • "That plate is hot. If you touch it, you’ll burn yourself."
  • "Tom won’t pass the exam. He hasn’t studied hard enough."
  • "When will you get your exam results?"

Expressing Probability and Expectations

"Will" is often paired with words like "probably," "expect," "sure," "think," and "wonder" to express probability or expectations about the future. These expressions add nuance to your predictions:

  • "I’ll probably be home late tonight."
  • "I haven’t seen Carol today. I expect she’ll phone this evening."
  • "Don’t worry about the exam. I’m sure you’ll pass."
  • "Do you think Sarah will like the present we bought her?"
  • "I don’t think the exam will be very difficult."
  • "I wonder what will happen."

Hopes and Wishes

When expressing hopes or wishes, "hope" is typically followed by the present tense, although "will" can also be used. For example, "I hope Kate passes the exam" is more common, but "I hope Kate will pass the exam" is also acceptable. Similarly, "I hope it doesn’t rain tomorrow" is a standard expression of hope.

Using "Will" for Present Situations

While "will" is primarily used for future contexts, it can occasionally describe present situations, particularly when making assumptions. For instance, "Don’t phone Ann now. She’ll be busy," suggests a current assumption about Ann's status.

The Use of "Shall"

"Shall" is less common in modern English and is primarily used with "I" and "we" to indicate future actions. It is more formal and often found in legal or formal documents. In everyday conversation, "I will" or "we will" is more prevalent.

Examples include:

  • "I shall be late this evening." (or "I will be")
  • "We shall probably go to Scotland in the summer." (or "We will probably go")

The negative form of "shall" is "shall not" or "shan’t," as in "I shan’t be here tomorrow," which can also be expressed as "I won’t be here tomorrow."

Common Mistakes and FAQs

Can "shall" be used with subjects other than "I" and "we"?

No, "shall" is traditionally used only with "I" and "we." Using "shall" with other subjects, such as "he," "she," "it," "you," or "they," is incorrect. For example, "She shall be very angry" should be "She will be very angry."

Is "shall" used in American English?

"Shall" is less common in American English and is often replaced by "will." However, it can still appear in formal or legal contexts.

Is "will" always correct for future tense?

While "will" is widely used for future tense, it's important to consider context. For planned events or decisions, other forms like "going to" or present continuous may be more appropriate.

Practical Exercises

Exercise 1: Fill in the blanks

Choose the correct form of "will" or "shall" to complete the sentences:

  1. Next week, I ______ (will/shall) visit my grandparents.
  2. We ______ (will/shall) probably see you at the party.
  3. She ______ (won’t/shall not) be happy if you’re late.
  4. ______ (Will/Shall) you help me with this project?
  5. I ______ (don’t think/shall not) it ______ (will/shall) rain tomorrow.

Exercise 2: Rewrite the sentences

Rewrite the sentences using the correct form of "will" or "shall":

  1. I think she (pass) ______ the exam.
  2. We (probably/go) ______ to the beach this weekend.
  3. They (not/finish) ______ the project on time.
  4. Do you think it (snow) ______ tomorrow?
  5. I (be) ______ late for the meeting tonight.

Conclusion

Mastering the use of "will" and "shall" enhances your ability to communicate future intentions, predictions, and expectations effectively. While "will" is the go-to choice for most future scenarios, understanding the nuances of "shall" can add formality and precision to your language, particularly in written or legal contexts. By practicing these forms and considering context, you can convey your messages with clarity and confidence.

Will vs shall: formal choices that sound natural - Blog ProseBoost